Understanding the meaning of Hindu festivals – P. Panikkar

Holi festival in UP.

If you find every Hindu festival problematic, perhaps the problem lies in your own understanding of these festivals, which seems to be shaped by a narrow and reductive reading of their cultural significance. And judging by the tenor of much of the online discourse, there is every chance that this understanding is clouded by ideological prejudices and a deeply misguided interpretation of secularism. – Prajesh Panikkar

Hindu festivals, with their exuberance, imperfections and diversity, deserve understanding and engagement, and, where necessary, constructive criticism, not reflexive condemnation

It has now become a trend to bash Hindu festivals and cultural practices, without any understanding or introspection, as though that alone were enough to earn you progressive credentials among liberals in our country.

Every Diwali, every Onam, every Karwa Chauth, and every Holi becomes an occasion for unsolicited lectures from all and sundry, from Bollywood celebrities and the left-liberal academic establishment in universities such as JNU to the self-appointed liberal intelligentsia on Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and YouTube. They are all eager to tell us why the way Hindus celebrate their festivals is primitive, how these festivals supposedly reek of casteism, and in some cases, why they should not be celebrated at all.

Interestingly, the same crowd is far more indulgent towards non-Hindu religious festivals, even when the ritual slaughter of large numbers of animals is an integral part of some of the celebrations. The silence is even more striking when one considers how vocal these same people are in criticising Karwa Chauth, yet how reluctant they are to question religious practices and doctrines that prescribe restrictive codes of conduct for women, dictate how they should dress, or insist that they remain confined to their homes rather than participate in public life. These are hardly obscure or marginal questions. They concern the everyday freedom, dignity and autonomy of women. Yet, those who are quick to lecture Hindus on the regressive elements of their religious traditions often have remarkably little to say about such practices elsewhere. Their response is not always limited to silence, either. At times, they even mock the press for reporting objectionable and deeply regressive statements made by religious figures.

It was Emile Durkheim who wrote about how collective rituals produce what he called “collective effervescence”. Religious festivals are perhaps among the clearest manifestations of this phenomenon. Festivals are, more often than not, occasions when a society reaffirms its collective identity and reminds itself of what binds its members together. Just as communication is impossible when only one person knows a language, a festival derives its meaning from the fact that an entire community understands and participates in its shared symbols, rituals and expressions. Everyone knows the language of the festival, and through its celebration, that shared language is renewed and passed on. When a celebrity treats Diwali as a nuisance to be managed, it reflects a failure to understand what is actually being practised. It is a failure to learn the cultural language of the society in which one lives. If anything, such an attitude is the very opposite of what liberalism and progressive values ought to stand for.

One reason such erroneous views are mistaken for marks of progressiveness is a fundamentally flawed understanding of Indian secularism. It seems that many of these self-proclaimed ‘progressives’ believe that bashing the religion of the majority (or, in many cases, denouncing their own religion) earns them points and makes them more committed secularists.

Festivals, particularly Hindu festivals, are often messy, noisy and excessive. Whether it is Holi, Diwali or Onam, this exuberance and lack of restraint are hard to miss. An Indian village on the eve of a Hindu festival looks quite unlike the serene, almost deserted streets of a European city on Christmas Day. On Onam, the streets, village corners and public spaces across Kerala become energetic, chaotic and boisterous, filled with celebration, joy and laughter. The same is true of an ordinary neighbourhood in Uttar Pradesh on the day of Holi. This temporary suspension of everyday order and restraint is, in many ways, what defines the festival.

One Western scholar, writing about Holi, describes this phenomenon as ‘licensed rebellion’. But where does this licence come from? It comes from the society in which the festival is celebrated, from a shared understanding of its cultural language and from the willingness of the community to participate in it. It is a mistake to interpret this apparent disorder as the absence of social order. It is an expression of a different kind of social order, one that the community recognises, understands and, for a brief period, collectively embraces.

Of course, there may be instances of excess that go beyond what is permissible, and celebrations may occasionally cross legitimate boundaries. But such things can happen at any festival or celebration, irrespective of religion or occasion. These excesses do not define any festival. To suggest so is also an attempt to make those who celebrate them feel diminished and guilty. Beneath the polished language of criticism, the underlying message is unmistakable: you should be ashamed of celebrating this festival. No festival, or indeed any collective celebration, should be judged solely by its occasional excesses while its cultural meaning, social function and the genuine joy it brings to people are overlooked.

Unfortunately, this is precisely what it looks like when celebrities publicly bash festivals, often invoking issues such as firecrackers, patriarchy or the mythology underlying the celebrations. Rather than engaging with these practices in their cultural and social context, they seem more interested in using them as an opportunity to score brownie points and project an image of themselves as secular and progressive. In the process, they reduce complex cultural practices to a handful of alleged transgressions and overlook everything else that gives these festivals their meaning.

Children watch Diwali fireworks.

If fireworks and the pollution they cause are the first things that come to your mind when you think of Diwali, if the inconvenience caused by the celebration is what you immediately associate with Holi, and if caste oppression and the subordination of marginalised communities are all that you can interpret from the mythology surrounding Onam, the problem is not with these festivals. As they say, if everywhere you go, you find yourself complaining about the stench, perhaps it is time to look under your own shoes. If you find every Hindu festival problematic, perhaps the problem lies in your own understanding of these festivals, which seems to be shaped by a narrow and reductive reading of their cultural significance. And judging by the tenor of much of the online discourse, there is every chance that this understanding is clouded by ideological prejudices and a deeply misguided interpretation of secularism.

There is nothing wrong with critically examining a religious tradition or festival. One is entitled to question the festivities, point out their excesses and draw attention to aspects of them that one finds objectionable. But to do so without understanding the cultural language of the festival or appreciating the spirit in which it is celebrated is not constructive. Criticism should not become an expression of self-righteousness or contempt.

Unfortunately, much of this so-called ‘criticism’ comes from a moral pedestal, with the critic, most often an activist or a protester, looking down upon those who celebrate the tradition.

Hindu festivals, with all their exuberance, imperfections, symbolism and diversity, deserve understanding and engagement, and, where necessary, constructive criticism, not reflexive condemnation. After all, being progressive should mean learning to understand one’s society better, not finding ever more ingenious ways to express contempt for it. – News18, 6 November 2026

› Prajesh Panikkar is a commentator with a research degree in philosophy from the University of Sheffield, focusing on the intersections of culture, history, and politics.

Chhath puja in North India.

The Rediscovery of India that is Bharat – Francois Gautier

Francois Gautier & Narendra Modi

Contrary to Sonia Gandhi, I have nothing to give or prove to Bharat. It is Bharat which has given everything to me. Indeed, like Mother Teresa before her, Sonia Gandhi seemed to me to approach India through a Western Catholic prism: as if India is a country that needs to be guided, corrected, uplifted or even lectured. – Francois Gautier

Sonia Gandhi and I have something in common. We were both born in Europe, both raised in the Catholic tradition, both married Indians, and both eventually made India our home. But the comparison stops there.

I came to India as a young Frenchman, with my Western education, Christian background and European prejudices. I knew practically nothing about this extraordinary civilisation. Yet, from the moment I arrived in Delhi, having driven from Paris in a caravan of five cars at the tender age of 19, I felt I had come home.

Slowly, through years of living among Indians, travelling across the country, studying its ancient wisdom and meeting its spiritual masters, I discovered a civilisation far greater, deeper and more sophisticated than anything I had imagined. Knowledge came down the ages via the Hindus, this unique people who had been so much persecuted.

Therefore, contrary to Sonia Gandhi, I have nothing to give or prove to Bharat. It is Bharat which has given everything to me. Indeed, like Mother Teresa before her, Sonia Gandhi seemed to me to approach India through a Western Catholic prism: as if India is a country that needs to be guided, corrected, uplifted or even lectured.

I observed Sonia’s political career at close range during my decades as a journalist covering South Asia. What struck me was not simply her rapid ascent within the Congress, but the ease with which she appeared to accept the reverence, privileges and extraordinary deference surrounding her.

I remember being so shocked when she got re-elected as president of the party in November 2000: she came in cavalcade of cars from her Janpath residence-fortress to her party’s office on Akbar Road just a few hundred metres away, surrounded by dozens of security, and Congress workers touching her feet—so impervious, arrogant like a ‘white memsahib’.

Her mother-in-law Indira Gandhi being shot by her Sikh bodyguards and her husband Rajiv being killed by a Sri Lankan Tamil separatist must have traumatised her. But personal tragedy cannot confer a hereditary right to govern a nation of 1.4 billion people.

This is why I was even more shocked that when constitutionally she was only an MP, during the UPA’s 10 years in power (2004-14), she behaved as the sovereign of India, Manmohan Singh being the puppet prime minister. The unfortunate karma of the Congress is that it was created by an Englishman and it remains even today a colonised party, which instinctively accords greater prestige to Westerners.

In her just-released book, Belonging: A Journey of Love, Sonia says, “I cried as I watched the demolition of Babri Masjid”—where nobody was killed on site.

But did she cry when 59 innocent Hindus, including 37 women and children, were burnt like animals in the Sabarmati Express in February 2002? No, certainly not!

My greatest concern today is that Rahul Gandhi appears to have inherited much of his mother’s political outlook. He speaks frequently of democracy, equality and constitutional values. These are noble principles. But I remain unconvinced because I think he has the same Westernised, Catholic-centric view of India and of Hindus in particular.

He will never understand—nor will his sister Priyanka—that India is not simply a geographical territory, an electoral arithmetic or a collection of communities competing for political concessions. India is Bharat. It is a civilisation whose spiritual and philosophical achievements stretch back thousands of years. It gave humanity the Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita, yoga, profound systems of metaphysics and an extraordinary tradition of religious pluralism.

One cannot hope to govern India successfully without understanding this inheritance.

Hindus have traditionally accepted many paths to the divine, they have often hesitated to defend their own traditions forcefully. I believe that Sonia Gandhi and the Congress establishment shamelessly exploited—and still do—this generosity.

For centuries, European powers dominated much of the world politically, economically and intellectually. They colonised Asia and Africa, and persuaded generations of educated people that Western civilisation represented the summit of human progress. That era is ending. The hour of Asia has come.

Bharat has an exceptional role to play in this transformation, not merely as an economic or military power, but as a spiritual and civilisational force. I continue, therefore, to place my faith in Narendra Modi.

I do not believe his government is beyond criticism. Indeed, I have criticised the BJP when I felt it failed to defend Hindu interests. But Modi has accomplished something historically significant: he has helped restore to millions of Indians a sense of pride in their own civilisation. He has challenged the assumption that India must imitate the West to become modern. I believe he remains the strongest political instrument of that rediscovery. – The New Indian Express, 16 November 2026

› Francois Gautier is a French journalist, author and former South Asia correspondent for Le Figaro.

Sonia Gandhi Cartoon

How Shivaji Maharaj killed Afzal Khan – Aabhas Maldahiyar

Shivaji strikes Afzal Khan.

For Shivaji’s contemporaries and those who came after them, Afzal Vadh became more than the death of a general. It became the moment when defiance ceased to be a gamble and became a force. … On 10 November 1659, history did not just record a death, it witnessed the prologue of a legend. – Aabhas Maldahiyar

There are moments when history seems to hold its breath. Then one man acts—and the fate of a people changes.

One such moment came 367 years ago, on 10 November 1659. Maharashtra remembers it as Afzal Vadh.

Afzal Khan was no ordinary adversary. Born, according to tradition, to a cook, he had risen to become one of the most formidable commanders of the Adil Shahi Sultanate of Bijapur, in present-day Karnataka. His remarkable ascent spoke for itself. He was regarded with exceptional favour by the Adil Shah, and had even once captured Aurangzeb. Of immense physical stature, he was described in sources such as the Shivabharat as a man of almost mountain-like build. His name inspired fear across the Deccan.

His own seal revealed the scale of his ambition, noting, “If exalted heaven were to display the excellence of the most excellent and the excellence of Afzal, then, instead of reciting the tasbih, every angel would proclaim: ‘Afzal is excellent!’ The quintessence of well-wishers, the conqueror of kingdoms, the destroyer of rebels and kafirs, the breaker of idols, the foremost conqueror of the lands of Malabar and Karnataka, the paragon of the age, possessor of the seat of dignity and valour: Afzal Khan-i-Muhammad Shahi! May he remain under divine protection.”

But the events of November 10, 1659, were preceded by devastation, diplomacy, threats, and finally the road to Pratapgad.

For weeks, Shivaji had watched the storm approach. Afzal Khan came with an army behind him and destruction in his wake. Temples were desecrated, settlements devastated, and negotiations exchanged. But Shivaji understood what lay beneath the courteous language.

This would be no ordinary meeting. It was a trap—or an opportunity. Perhaps both. And Shivaji was ready.

How did Shivaji prepare to turn Afzal Khan’s trap against him?

Before walking towards Afzal Khan, he had quietly prepared the battlefield. Infantry and cavalry had received their orders. Men waited silently in the surrounding hills, each contingent knowing its place and purpose. The Bandals and Silimkars were among those entrusted with crucial responsibilities.

The Jedhe Chronology (Shivacharitra Pradipa, pp. 19–20) records how Shivaji Maharaj anticipated treachery by Afzal Khan and carefully positioned his forces before their meeting at Pratapgad.

“At a confidential council held by Shivaji with his ministers and Kanhoji Jedhe, it was agreed that the mleccha [Afzal Khan] was a perfidious man. The Bandal deshmukh, together with his forces, would remain stationed in Jawali and the forest of Par,” according to the Jedhe Chronology.

“Should the Khan resort to treachery during the meeting, the Bandal deshmukh was to prevent the Khan’s army, encamped at Par, from ascending the mountain (to the fort) and was to come to my [Shivaji’s] assistance with a select body of men. … If, by the blessings of the goddess Shri Amba, Afzal Khan were slain, the Bandals, upon receiving a signal from the fort, would fall upon the enemy army at Par and destroy it utterly. Haibatrao and Balaji Naik Silimbkar, with their troops, were stationed at the Bochegholi Pass and were instructed not to allow the enemy to ascend through it,” it noted further.

The instructions show that Shivaji had prepared not just for the encounter with Afzal Khan, but also for the battle that could follow, with troops positioned to block the enemy’s routes towards Pratapgad.

The final pieces were in place. Shivaji had entrusted the Bandals with a task upon which everything might depend: to watch the road between the place of meeting and Afzal Khan’s camp at Par, and, at the appointed signal, fall upon the enemy. The Silimbkars guarded the Bochegholi Pass.

Beyond this, certainty fades. No contemporary source tells us exactly where every deshmukh stood or how Shivaji deployed the rest of his forces. Later chronicles offer a fuller picture, but not always a reliable one.

Yet the design is unmistakable. Shivaji had not walked towards Afzal Khan alone, nor unprepared. Every approach to Pratapgad had been considered. Men waited in the forests, along the passes and beside the narrow mountain roads, each knowing what was expected when the signal came.

Then came 10 November 1659.

Beneath the towering heights of Pratapgad, Shivaji and Afzal Khan came face to face.

Only one of them would walk away.

Who struck first when Shivaji and Afzal Khan came face to face?

What happened in those fateful moments has been argued over for centuries. The surviving accounts differ over the weapons, the sequence and the instant when violence erupted.

Tiger Claws (Wagh Nakh)

Most say that Shivaji struck him with a dagger; a few add the wagh nakh, or tiger claws, a weapon fitted around the hand and capable of remaining concealed within a clenched fist. Nor do all the sources agree on who made the first move.

History, at this point, offers competing versions rather than perfect certainty. The account followed here is that of the Shivabharat, the most reliable source for the events surrounding the meeting.

Yet beneath these differences lies one fact that no version can erase. Whatever weapon was used, whoever struck first, and however the desperate struggle unfolded, Shivaji had entered that meeting resolved that Afzal Khan must not leave it alive.

How did a peaceful embrace turn into Afzal Khan’s death?

The Shivabharat captures the moment in these words: “Shivaji began his preparations for the meeting when he learnt that Afzal Khan had set out for the appointed place at the foot of Pratapgad Fort. Following the counsel of the priests, he worshipped Lord Shiva in the prescribed manner and, as was his daily custom, distributed alms. After a light meal, he occasionally sipped pure water and spent a few moments in silent prayer to the goddess Tulaja. He then dressed for the occasion and glanced at his reflection in a mirror.”

Rising at once, he paid his respects to the priest and the other Brahmins and received their blessings. He gazed upon the sun before giving a cow and her calf, along with gold, in daan to a virtuous Brahmin. Meanwhile, he secretly stationed his bravest followers, eager to accompany him, for the defence of Pratapgad Fort.

He then set out to receive the Muslim (Afzal Khan), who had come with treachery in his heart, with the outward cordiality due to a guest. Beneath his robes, Shivaji wore fine armour. A white turban adorned with a hackle crowned his head, while his robe was sprinkled with saffron. With a sword in one hand and a patta in the other, he resembled Lord Vishnu incarnate, bearing a sword in one hand and a mace in the other.

Shivaji descended the fort on foot with a brisk step. Afzal saw him approaching, and Shivaji, too, met the gaze of his adversary with a smile.

The Khan, anxious to dispel any suspicion from Shivaji’s mind, handed his sword to an attendant standing nearby. Then, feigning warmth and friendship, he called out in a loud voice, “Oh, you who feign an eagerness for war and behave with such wilfulness! You have strayed onto the wrong path and, in your arrogance, show no regard for the Adilshah, the Qutbshah, or the mighty Timurid Emperor. I have come to chastise you for your insolence. Abandon these mountain forts and cast aside your avarice. Submit to me, and I shall personally take you to Bijapur, make you bow before my victorious master, Ali Adilshah, plead your cause before him, and secure for your great wealth.”

“O son of Shahji, child! Cast away your pride in your own wisdom. Let me take your hand in mine. Come, embrace me,” Khan added.

With these words, Khan drew Shivaji’s neck beneath his left arm and struck his side with a dagger. Quick and agile, Shivaji broke free from his grasp, parried the blow, and drove his own sword into the Khan’s stomach.

Stunned by the wound, the Khan tried to hold back his spilling entrails and cried out that he had been slain. At once, his servant rushed towards Shivaji, Khan’s sword raised to strike. Khan had brought this man into his entourage knowing that Shivaji would never kill a Brahmin. Shivaji parried the blow and, wielding his patta, cleft Khan’s head in two.

Thus, at noon on Thursday, 10 November 1659, Shivaji slew Afzal Khan, the enemy of the Devas.

What happened to Afzal Khan’s men after Shjivaji killed him?

In the confusion that followed, another figure briefly enters the record: a Brahmin in Afzal Khan’s service. The Shivabharat says that one of the Khan’s Brahmin servants attacked Shivaji, but gives neither his name nor his fate. Later sources identify him as Krishnaji Bhaskar, though their accounts conflict.

Some manuscripts of the AK Chronicle state that Krishnaji struck at Shivaji and missed, whereupon Shivaji spared him because he was a Brahmin. Another version says that Krishnaji did attack, but Shivaji refused to kill him on account of his Brahmin status; Jiva Mahala, it claims, dealt the fatal blow.

The truth is difficult to recover. The killing of a Brahmin was regarded as a grave sin, and Shivaji was not untouched by the religious beliefs of his age (for the broader belief, see Shivacharitra Sahitya, vol. I, nos. 15, 48; Cosme da Guarda, in Surendranath Sen, ed., Foreign Biographies of Shivaji, 102; Marhycy Itihsc Sdhane, vol. VIII, no. 24). Yet beneath that tent, there was little room for such calculations. Afzal Khan had already attacked Shivaji, and violence had erupted around them. It is therefore difficult to imagine Shivaji consciously sparing an armed assailant merely because he was a Brahmin.

Perhaps Krishnaji Bhaskar was killed by another hand, and the latter writers turned the circumstance into a story of deliberate restraint. Only one version explicitly says that he survived. Against it stands the silence of the Shivabharat, the earliest and most important narrative of the encounter. On balance, Krishnaji Bhaskar probably did not survive.

But there was scarcely time to consider the dead.

The moment Afzal Khan fell, 10 of his men rushed towards Shivaji: Abdul Sayyid, Bada Sayyid, Rahim Khan—Afzal Khan’s nephew—Pahlawan Khan, four other Muslim guards, and Pilaji and Shankaraji Mohite.

Shivaji met them with a sword and a patta. His own 10 guards rushed forward: Sambhaji Kawji, Kataji Ingale, Kondaji Kank, Yesaji Kank, Krishnaji Gayakwad, Suryaji Kakade, Jiva Mahala, Visaji Murumbak, Sambhaji Karwar and Siddi Ibrahim, an Abyssinian Muslim.

For a few violent moments, Shivaji’s life depended upon the men around him. Bada Sayyid moved to strike, but Jiva Mahala cut him down before the blow could fall. Shivaji’s guards then descended upon Afzal Khan’s remaining bodyguards in the furious melee that followed, according to Shivabhrata.

The meeting had begun with ceremony and professions of courtesy. Within minutes, Afzal Khan was dead.

The private encounter was over, and the battle had begun.

How did the killing of Afzal Khan elevate Shivaji into a legend?

Sabhasad records as below on what followed. “The Raja himself slew the Khan in single combat—a man who was a veritable Duryodhana, as formidable in bodily strength as he was wicked at heart. Just as Bhima had slain his adversary single-handed, so too did the Raja. Shivaji Raja was Bhima himself; it was he who slew Afzal. Such a deed could not have been accomplished by an ordinary mortal. Surely, he was an incarnation, and only thus could he have performed such a feat. Victory was won.”

Adnyandas carried the vision further (Aitihsik Powe, pt. I, 22). Shivaji, to him, was no ordinary mortal raised by courage or fortune, but a divine force sent for a purpose. In his struggle echoed an older sacred war: as Rama had stood against mighty Ravana, Shivaji rose alone against overwhelming odds.

Three hundred and sixty-seven years later, the arguments over every weapon, every blow and every moment beneath that tent continue. History may never recover every detail. But it cannot erase what followed. At Pratapgad, a young ruler confronted a vastly more powerful adversary who had come to crush him, and Afzal Khan did not return.

For Shivaji’s contemporaries and those who came after them, Afzal Vadh became more than the death of a general. It became the moment when defiance ceased to be a gamble and became a force. Perhaps that is why Maharashtra has never forgotten the day. Empires possessed armies, wealth and power. Shivaji possessed a mountain, a handful of loyal men, the will to refuse surrender, and last but not the least—the blessings of Maa Bhawani.

On 10 November 1659, history did not just record a death, it witnessed the prologue of a legend. – India Today, 10 November 2026

› Aabhas Maldahiyar is an author, architect and historian.

Tulaja Bhavani blesses Shivaji's sword.

India should replace the UK on the UN Security Council – Michael Rubin

UN Security Council

With the unravelling of the last aspects of the British Empire, the notion that the United Kingdom should have any seat as a permanent member of the UN Security Council has no logical or moral basis. – Michael Rubin

That the structure of the United Nations is antiquated is not news. The Security Council rewarded the victors of World War II, but ignored both their colonial holdings, the practical impact of decolonization, and general shifts over eight decades.

Upon the United Nations’ founding, for example, 74 countries were independent including those like Germany and Japan still under occupation. Of these, 51 became UN members. Today, the UN has 193 members, plus the Holy See and Palestine, both of which have observer status.

The Security Council is important; it provides a check on the General Assembly’s mob mentality and also resolves the problem of tiny autocracies like Guinea-Bissau having as much power as industrialized democracies like India or Germany. Yet it is also archaic.

The United Kingdom symbolizes how dated and unjust some membership on the Security Council is. In 1945, the United Kingdom’s share of the world’s economy was 6.5%, and that was despite the devastation of Nazi bombardment during World War II. Today, however, the International Monetary Fund estimates the British share at just half that. Today, by purchasing power parity, India ranks third globally and the United Kingdom ranks ninth.

Consider also population. In 1945, the United Kingdom’s population was just shy of five crores, while India under British rule had more than eight times as many people. Today, the United Kingdom’s population has just shy of seven crores; India has 148 crores.

As the United Nations prepares for the selection of a new secretary-general after eight years of António Guterres, India should use its diplomatic heft to demand reform now. Broad reform would be impossible in the short-term, but India has another out: Assuming the United Kingdom’s Security Council seat permanently.

Technically, any structural reform needs an amendment to the Charter, which each of the permanent five members of the Security Council can block. But there are precedents:

On December 17, 1963, the UN expanded the Security Council from 11 to 15 seats. Within the General Assembly. France and the Soviet Union voted no, the United States and United Kingdom abstained, and Taiwan voted in favour. Ultimately, however, all five ratified the amendment anyway.

Technically there is no withdrawal clause for Security Council membership, but there have been changes. Article 23 of the UN Charter recognizes the “Republic of China” and “USSR” rather than their successors, the People’s Republic of China and Russia. In both instances, the seat changed hands without an amendment. Taiwan lost its seat in a credentialling vote, while the Soviet Union ceded its seat based on a no-objection letter.

The United Kingdom recognizes that it no longer deserves its permanent Security Council seat; it is a vestige of its imperialist past for which its government continues to make amends.

On May 22, 2025, the United Kingdom and Mauritius signed a treaty committing the United Kingdom to transfer sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, though the United States and United Kingdom would retain a 99-year-lease over the Diego Garcia base for an annual payment of approximately £101 million to Mauritius. The United Kingdom has not yet ratified the deal though, largely due to President Donald Trump’s opposition. With the midterm elections confirming Trump’s lame duck status, though, this is likely a temporary problem. Regardless, it does not change the bigger shift in British self-awareness.

Today’s Chagos will likely be tomorrow’s Cyprus. The United Kingdom still claims 3% of Cyprus, in theory as sovereign base areas, but London has consistently betrayed Nicosia. The British did nothing when Turkey occupied one-third the country nor did the United Kingdom act when Iran launched drones against Cyprus. The sad reality is that Britain occupies Cyprus to use its beaches as a resort and little more.

British control over the Falkland Islands are also again at stake; after all, it is hard to justify recognition of Palestine and not simultaneously acknowledge Argentine sovereignty over Las Malvinas.

With the unravelling of the last aspects of the British Empire, the notion that the United Kingdom should have any seat as a permanent member of the UN Security Council has no logical or moral basis.

India should demand the United Kingdom voluntarily relinquish its seat and that the new secretary-general, whomever he or she might be, support that decision as a condition of receiving Indian support. Prime Minister Narendra Modi should further demand that the support of Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio are the price of resuming the bilateral relationship gratuitously shredded early in the second Trump term. Russia will support India, and France has no reason to object. One West European Security Council permanent member is enough. China may be more reluctant but may not veto. Beijing’s own veto will protect Pakistan, and China has much to lose in its own quest for appointments and General Assembly influence if it stymies New Delhi. After all, the Global South would cheer for India’s new status, seeing a crack in the door to UN reform while bringing insufferable Britain down to size. – The Sunday Guardian, 8 Novermber 2026

› Michael Rubin is Director of Policy Analysis at the Middle East Forum in Washington, DC, and a Distinguished Fellow at the Usanas Foundation in Udaipur.

UN NYC headquarters with India flag in the flag row.

The secularisation of Diwali – Utpal Kumar

Diwali Lamps

The problem with the “Festival of Lights” narrative is that it seeks to secularise Diwali by divorcing it from its sacred roots. It distorts the Indic notion of festivity—one that embraces diversity while being bound by a shared civilisational core. – Utpal Kumar

We are living in an era of great Hindu awakening. After centuries of civilisational amnesia imposed through colonisation, political manipulation, and intellectual distortion, Hindus are rediscovering who they are. There is a growing self-awareness and self-esteem—a recognition that Sanatana Dharma is not a relic of the past but a living, breathing continuum that is as ancient as it is modern, as sacred as it is rational, and as religious as it is scientific.

Yet, as this consciousness rises, so too does a more sophisticated form of opposition. Gone are the crude, overt attacks on Hinduism. The new offensive is subtler: it praises the tradition outwardly while hollowing it out from within. The sacred is stripped away, leaving behind only a cultural shell—sanitised, commercialised, and secularised.

Diwali is a classic example.

Once a deeply spiritual celebration grounded in profound human and moral values, Diwali is now often reduced to a vague “festival of lights” symbolising the victory of “good over evil” and “light over darkness”—but stripped of its rich Hindu context. While these phrases aren’t inherently wrong, divorced from their sacred roots they detach Diwali from the core religio-cultural traditions that give it true meaning: the joyous return of Sri Rama to Ayodhya, Krishna’s slaying of Narakasura, and Goddess Kali’s triumph over demonic forces.

Imagine if Christmas were explained merely as a “festival of love conquering hate”, with all references to Jesus erased. That’s what has happened to Diwali. No gods, no demons, no religion, no story—just a feel-good celebration. At this rate, even “light” might soon be declared polluting. Recall how a Samajwadi Party leader recently questioned the rationale of spending on diyas, drawing parallels with Christmas celebrations abroad, and suggested Bharat should emulate them. One day, someone may well ask why Diwali is even needed when Christmas is just a month away. Why not club the two together—to save money for a “poor” country like Bharat?

And this secularisation—or should one say desacralisation?—is not accidental. Each Hindu festival now faces its own “civilising campaign”. Before Diwali, one is compulsively reminded to save the environment; before Holi, the campaign gains ground to conserve water; before Raksha Bandhan, gender rights come to the fore; and before Shivratri, one witnesses an online movement to stop “wasting milk”. Under the guise of modern-day morality and sensibility, the sacred fabric of these festivals is systematically targeted and assaulted.

Environmental consciousness and social justice are causes worth emulating, but their selective invocation only against Hindu festivals betrays their dubious, anti-Hindu intent.

The problem with the “Festival of Lights” narrative is that it seeks to secularise Diwali by divorcing it from its sacred roots. It distorts the Indic notion of festivity—one that embraces diversity while being bound by a shared civilisational core.

Diwali in the North celebrates Rama’s homecoming; in the South, Krishna’s victory over Narakasura; and in Bengal, Kali’s triumph over demons. In Tamil homes, Diwali morning begins with an oil bath, invoking the presence of Goddess Lakshmi and the sacred waters of the Ganga. “Ganga snanam aacha?” (Have you had your holy dip in the River Ganga?): This is a customary greeting exchanged on Diwali, referring to the ceremonial oil bath. Invoking Ganga manifests a strong sense of civilisational unity in the Sanatana Dharma.

Such assaults aren’t just limited to the popular/cultural arena; they run deeper into academia as well. Sheldon Pollock, a prominent American Indologist, for instance, has interpreted Sanskrit texts and traditions as a tool of oppression and elitism. In his book The Battle for Sanskrit, Rajiv Malhotra exposes how Pollock has worked tirelessly to strip Sanskrit of its sacred identity.

The American Indologist, for instance, has accused Sanskrit of “Brahmin elitism”, besides influencing British colonialism and German Nazism. Pollock describes Sanskrit as “at once a record of civilisation and a record of barbarism—of extraordinary inequality and other social poisons”.

His discomfort with Sanskrit’s Sanatana roots is such that he interprets the Ramayana as a political code through which “proto-communalist relations could be activated and theocratic legitimations rendered”. He alleges that the Ramayana’s portrayal of Ravan and the Rakshasas as “others” forms the ideological foundation for later-day hatred for Muslims. In his view, the sacred Hindu epic itself has been instrumental in legitimising violence against Muslims.

Pollock’s dangerous assertions aren’t mere academic theories. They are ideological weapons designed to delegitimise Hindu civilisation by attacking its moral and spiritual core.

When sacred stories are desacralised, the culture they sustain begins to erode. Once memory fades, replacement histories can be written. That is how a civilisation is colonised—this time, not by armies, but by narratives.

The battle, therefore, is not about fireworks or rituals—it’s about their sacred, innate meaning. It’s about whether Hindus will continue to define their festivals, their texts, and their traditions, or whether others will define them for them.

As Kundera warned, when people lose their memory, they lose themselves.

The “modern” sanitisation of Hindu festivals, the intellectual deconstruction of its sacred texts, and the cultural detachment from its civilisational roots are all parts of the same process—a slow liquidation of Bharat’s civilisational identity.

Diwali is merely the battleground; the real target is Sanatana Dharma. – Firstpost, 21 octoberv 2025

Utpal Kumar is Opinion Editor at Firstpost and News18 and is the author of the book Eminent Distorians: Twists and Truths in Bharat’s History.

George Orwell Quote

Emperor Xi’s War Lab – Ravi Shankar

President Xi Jinping (born 15 June 1953) is a Chinese politician who is the paramount leader of China. He has served as the general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and chairman of the Party Central Military Commission (CMC) since 2012, and as the president of China and chairman of the State Central Military Commission since 2013.

“Let China sleep, for when she wakes, she will shake up the world.” – Napoleon Bonaparte

Napoleon’s prophecy is about two centuries old. It is coming true now. The man who has awakened it is Xi Jinping, China’s paramount leader (Zuigao Lingdaorén), General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party, and its powerful nationalist president since 2013. His Made in China 2025 policy seeks to realise the Chinese dream of world hegemony. His instrument is self-reliance: reducing China’s dependence on foreign technology to become a fully capable military manufacturing power in its own right.

That technology is what Napoleon warned the world about. The warning is echoed by a capable officer who knows the India-China frontier not as a line on a map but as a difficult, unforgiving stretch of mountains where weather, altitude, distance and the smallest movement of troops can have strategic consequences. On October 22, the Director General of the Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP), Shatrujeet Kapur, warned: “To face China through traditional ways would be tough now. Because China has invested heavily in the modernisation of its forces and has moved ahead. But through drones, small nations can fight bigger nations, as we have seen in the Russia-Ukraine and Iran-US conflicts. Russia is sacrificing 10,000-15,000 soldiers every month.”

The warning came a week before the Fifth Plenum. Past sessions have reaffirmed Xi’s position as the “core” of the Party. The abolition of presidential term limits in 2018 opened the way for him to remain in power indefinitely. His personal philosophy, known as “Xi Jinping Thought”, is being elevated to a status comparable to that of Mao Zedong’s ideological doctrine. Xi has unleashed a wave of purges of Party and government officials for “moral corruption”—a term often used as shorthand for those perceived as insufficiently loyal to the 73-year-old strongman. Estimates from the Asia Society Policy Institute suggest that only two of the 44 military members of the Central Committee in 2022 have survived the purge. The number is the same in the seven-member Central Military Commission, which oversees China’s armed forces: only Xi Jinping and one other general remain.

What does this mean for Xi, China, India and the world? Following the Fifth Plenum, Xi is set to consolidate his position as the most powerful man in China and one of the most powerful leaders in the world. Under his leadership, China has taken a quantum leap across the vectors that determine global power: technology, military strength, the economy, diplomacy, and development.

Supertech Sultan

Xi, to strengthen China’s position against its top competitor United States, has ordered investments in billions in advanced chips, artificial intelligence, and renewable energy. China now dominates global supplies of several industrial, automotive, and defence micro controllers, and is integrating AI into national security, and pursuing its “AI Plus” strategy to expand Chinese software across Global South markets.

Its “Big Three”—electric vehicles, lithium-ion batteries and solar energy—have become major export engines, replacing the traditional “Old Three” of clothing, furniture and home appliances. A “New New Three”, comprising AI software, industrial and humanoid robotics, and biotechnology, is emerging. Dr. Srikanth Kondapalli, Professor of China Studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University, traces this rise to science and technology initiatives launched in the 1980s, including the 863 Programme, which targeted robotics, telecommunications, space technology and biotechnology. “Today, China is a major player in 5G, solar manufacturing, electric vehicles, batteries and critical-mineral refining, and is advancing towards 6G. However, technological dominance does not mean complete self-reliance. Semiconductors remain a key weakness.” Although China has advanced in seven-nanometre chip technology, it still trails the US in aspects of semiconductor manufacturing. Nevertheless, Dr. Kondapalli argues, sustained technological investment remains central to Xi’s ambitions to create economic assets and China-centric global influence.

Defence Dragon

This is where the maximum growth is, since China is the world’s second largest defence spender: its official defence budget 2025 was about $245 billion—up by 7.2 per cent the previous year. The real spending is substantially higher, because R&D and the People’s Armed Police are partly excluded. The PLA’s 13 group armies spread across the five theatre commands has 4,500-5,000 main battle tanks including several hundred Type 15 light tanks built for high-altitude areas like Tibet and Ladakh; thousands of armoured personnel and infantry fighting vehicles, self-propelled howitzers PCL-181, and long-range rocket systems PHL-03 and PHL-16; Z-10 attack helicopters and Z-20 utility helicopters. China has the world’s largest navy: roughly 370 ships and submarines. It has three aircraft carriers with electromagnetic catapults, 8 -10 Destroyers, innumerable frigates, amphibious ship helicopter assault ships, 6 ballistic-missile subs, 6 nuclear attack subs, 48 diesel-electric subs, a naval aviation arm with J-15 carrier fighters, with the J-35 and the KJ-600 early-warning aircraft for aircraft carrier use. Air Force (PLAAF) and naval aviation together operate about 3,000 aircraft, including over 2,400 combat aircraft, making this the largest air force in Asia: J-20 stealth fighters, J-16, J-10C, J-11, Su-30 and Su-35, and now J-35 stealth fighter entering service. Stealth bomber H-20 is under development. China’s huge drone fleet is fast-growing, and includes the WZ-7 high-altitude surveillance drone, the WZ-8 supersonic reconnaissance drone and the GJ-11 stealth combat drone. Dramatic growth has been in rocket force and nuclear arsenal: over 600 operational nuclear warheads as of mid-2024, up by 400 in 2019, with more than 1,000 projected by 2030. Its missile inventory includes ICBMs DF-41, DF-31AG and silo-based DF-5 variants, the DF-26 intermediate-range missile (nicknamed the “Guam killer”), the DF-21D anti-ship missile (“carrier killer”), and the DF-17 hypersonic glide missile. It has estimated the world’s largest inventory of land-based ballistic and cruise missiles. Chinese space and cyber forces operate over 1,000 satellites, of which 359 are ISR (intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance) systems, triple the 2018 figure. Since April 2024, space, cyber and information warfare have been handled by three dedicated forces: Aerospace, Cyberspace and Information Support. Dr. Saibal Dasgupta points out, military modernisation is about more than acquiring advanced weapons. “China’s priority is to establish global leadership in the eyes of its own people, counter American influence in its neighbourhood and achieve reunification with Taiwan. China has strengthened its Rocket Force and integrated AI, drones and robotics into military operations. However, technological superiority alone does not guarantee the ability to win wars.”

Economic Superman

Xi’s relentless drive for economic hegemony makes China the world’s second-largest economy, with a nominal GDP of approximately $21.5 trillion; it ranks first in purchasing power parity. Its research and development expenditure has grown and is now estimated at approximately $584-588 billion, making it the world’s second-largest spender in absolute terms. China ranks 12th globally in R&D intensity. Xi, by controlling Chinese businesses, has forced private corporations to bear the vast majority of the research costs, which are approximately 77.4 per cent of China’s R&D expenditure. This integration of government priorities, corporate investment and technological development is Xi’s brainchild to give Beijing the advantage in directing resources towards strategically important sectors. However, China’s economic and technological ascent has vulnerabilities. It is dependent on certain advanced semiconductor technologies. The PLA’s ability to translate technological superiority into battlefield success is yet to be proved in real-time action.

Diplomacy Daring

Xi Jinping’s defining diplomatic formula is “building a community with a shared future for mankind”—read helmed by China. The Communist country’s diplomatic clout has grown alongside its economic and military power. Its share of the UN’s regular budget is up from approximately 2.05 per cent in 2006 to around 20 per cent today. China is the second-largest contributor to UN peacekeeping operations and sends the largest contingent of peacekeepers among the Security Council’s permanent members. Through infrastructural investments, diplomatic partnerships and defence cooperation, Beijing continues to expand its strategic reach, particularly across the developing world.

Dr. Kondapalli places these ambitions in historical context. “When Xi Jinping came to power in 2012, he advanced three key concepts: the China Dream, national rejuvenation and a community of shared destiny.” The China Dream seeks global leadership in technology and the economy, while national rejuvenation involves reclaiming territories Beijing considers historically Chinese, including Taiwan and parts of the South and East China Seas. Together, these ambitions reflect China’s goal to become the world’s dominant power.

Yet India is far from incapable of challenging China. Its defence budget for FY 2026-27 is $ 7.85 lakh crore, approximately $86-93.5 billion, as the world’s fourth-largest military spender. China has around 2.035 million active-duty military personnel against India’s roughly 1.435 million. India’s challenge is not to simply match China tank for tank, aircraft for aircraft or ship for ship. Its ability to detect threats, process intelligence, make decisions without hesitation and coordinate military operations quicker and more effectively than its adversary is what matters.

Strategy Wiz

Counting tanks isn’t enough. In modern warfare, the side that sees first, thinks fastest and connects best has the advantage. Operation Sindoor underscored this lesson, placing C4ISR—Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance—at the centre of the confrontation. China has sought to exploit its capabilities through Pakistan, whose Chinese-made J-10C fighters reportedly targeted Indian Rafales with PL-15 missiles. Justin Bronk, an air-warfare specialist at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), told Reuters: “The Indians were not expecting to be shot at.” Lieutenant General Rahul R Singh described the China-Pakistan partnership through an ancient Chinese dictum: “killed by a borrowed knife.” Beijing, he suggested, could weaken India through its partner without directly confronting it on the border.

Singh revealed how Pakistan received real-time intelligence from China during the operation. “When the DGMO-level talks were going on, Pakistan was mentioning that we know that your such and such vector is primed and is ready for action,” he said. “So, they were getting live inputs from China, which is comparatively far from the theatre of action.” Retired British Air Marshal Greg Bagwell, a RUSI fellow, distilled the lesson: “The winner in this was the side that had the best situational awareness.”

Singh described India’s northern frontier as a “live lab” for China, which can assess its military technology through its Pakistan partnership. Operation Sindoor offered Beijing the opportunity to demonstrate its equipment power against Western systems. It had potential commercial consequences for the West. Indonesia, which has ordered Rafale fighters from France, is reportedly weighing the Chinese J-10.

Former ambassador and author Rajiv Dogra says, “China and Pakistan are virtually Siamese twins in military cooperation and defence technology.” Their joint Karakoram 2026 exercise in Xinjiang, held from October 14 to 23, highlights their union. China supports Pakistan’s nuclear technology, satellite capabilities, military aviation and telecommunications, and has emerged as Pakistan’s major defence supplier by upstaging the United States.

Dogra warns that the partnership has wider implications for India. His statistical model identifies an India–China or India-China-Pakistan conflict as a potential flashpoint for a major war. “Whether we look at our western or northern neighbour, India remains the common strategic consideration shaping their military cooperation,” he says.

Therefore, India’s challenge goes beyond disputed borders and touches satellite intelligence, cyber capabilities, defence manufacturing and the growing military coordination between Beijing and Islamabad.

Master of Symbols

Xi Jinping’s global strategy must be understood through China’s growing military and economic power. Sun Tzu’s maxim that “great results can be achieved with small forces” resonates in Xi’s philosophy. During his September 2014 visit to India, Xi took a riverside stroll with Prime Minister Modi and tried his hand at a charkha at Sabarmati Ashram. At the same time, approximately 1,000 Chinese troops entered Ladakh, withdrawing after Xi left. During his September visit to the BRICS summit, satellite images showed Chinese troops advancing into disputed territory along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). The lesson for New Delhi: summit selfies do not stop soldiers. There is no evidence he personally directed every military move, but China demonstrated its willingness to deploy substantial military resources to a border confrontation, using territorial claims and sustained pressure to influence negotiations. The pattern is striking: diplomatic warmth accompanied by conspicuous military manoeuvres. Chinese emperors understood symbolism; sometimes, a circle drawn by an emperor conveyed approval more powerfully than a direct command. So, Xi’s message is both subtle and clear: China is willing to negotiate, but on its own terms. Contrary to earlier American expectations that Beijing would accept the liberal international order and defer to Washington, its military moves in the South China Sea, Hong Kong, Taiwan and along the Indian border suggest otherwise. Xi’s global strategy is simple in its duality: expand Chinese regional influence while preparing to challenge American global leadership. Xi no longer wants merely to rule China. Whether he intends to extend that influence over India remains the million-dollar question along the border. But ambition does not guarantee success.

The One and only Ruler

The West is waking up to Xi’s China only now, having overlooked a crucial history lesson. For much of recorded history, China was a global centre of wealth, culture and technology. From the Xia, Shang and Zhou to the Qin and Han dynasties, successive emperors pursued the idea of a bigger, stronger and more unified China. Constraints of geography and internal divisions limited the reach.

While the West built the liberal international order after the Second World War, Xi’s “Chinese Dream” draws on a much older legacy, epitomised by Qin Shi Huang. In 221 BC, Qin became the First Emperor of a unified China by consolidating political, economic and cultural systems while expanding fortifications that laid the foundation for the Great Wall. He commissioned the Lingqu Canal, an extensive road network and a vast mausoleum guarded by the Terracotta Army. His achievements came at a terrible human cost. Through Legalism, an ancient Chinese authoritarian system, Qin Shi Huang enforced strict laws, harsh punishments and intellectual repression. Yet his vision of unity, stability and national strength continues to echo in Beijing’s gilded halls of power.

Xi Jinping appears to draw on a similar playbook. Before succeeding Hu Jintao, he remained relatively unknown to the world. His formative years as a “sent-down youth” living in a cave and doing arduous labour in rural Shaanxi, may have shaped his political resilience and appetite for risk. The province lies in the ancient Qin heartland, near Xianyang, the emperor’s former capital. The connection may be coincidental, but the parallels are striking. By 2017–18, Xi had consolidated personal power, dismantling collective leadership and benefiting from the abolition of presidential term limits in 2018. The post-Mao safeguards against one-man rule weakened, placing him at the centre of China’s political system more firmly than any leader in decades.

More than 2,200 years after Qin Shi Huang, China once again has a powerful leader whose ambitions invited comparisons with its imperial past. Xi’s supporters portray his anti-corruption campaign as necessary reform, while affectionate nicknames such as “Xi Dada” (Uncle Xi or Daddy Xi) helped cultivate a paternal public image. His wife, Peng Liyuan, became “Auntie Peng” or “Mother Peng”, while the viral 2014 music video Xi Dada Loves Peng presented the couple as approachable and relatable. But beneath this carefully cultivated image lies the central reality of Xi’s rule: concentration of power in one man’s hands, justified by the promise of national rejuvenation through strong, centralised leadership.

Economic Engineer

Geopolitical experts, presidents and tycoons all want to know what Xi Jinping is thinking. But guessing his psychological impulses is like guessing where a dragon will breathe fire next. The smarter approach is to follow the paper trail: the priorities Xi has hard-wired into the Chinese state. The picture that emerges is of a leader who sees China’s rise as his historical mission, treats security and economics as two sides of the same coin, builds global clout using every available instrument, and believes the project will succeed only if power remains firmly at the centre—preferably with him. The real story lies in how these pieces fit together. Weeks after becoming Party chief in November 2012, Xi toured a historical exhibition at Beijing’s National Museum and popularised the phrase that would define his era: the “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation”. A decade later, at the 20th Party Congress, the slogan remained central to his political vision. Its significance lies in the way it combines economic growth, military strength and diplomatic reach into a single historical narrative. China is not simply a developing country seeking prosperity; it is an ancient civilisation reclaiming what Beijing considers its rightful place after a century of humiliation.

Dr Kondapalli explains how this historical narrative forges China’s technological and strategic priorities. For Beijing, technological development is not an isolated economic objective but an instrument of national power. China’s investments in semiconductors, AI, robotics and advanced computing serves both its domestic development goals and its ambition to reduce dependence on foreign suppliers. The integration of civilian industrial innovation into military modernisation is particularly important. Technologies developed for commercial applications can be used to strengthen surveillance, communications, intelligence gathering and battlefield coordination as well.

This civil-military integration is central to Xi’s ambition to make China technologically self-reliant and militarily formidable. But the ability to innovate, coordinate forces, respond to uncertainty and sustain operations under pressure remains just as important. As Dasgupta notes, is the PLA’s advances in AI, drones and robotics that give China technological strength alone sufficient to ensure victory in war? The answer matters enormously for India, which faces China not only across a contested mountain frontier but also through a growing network of Chinese strategic partnerships, technological capabilities and military investments.

Mystery Man

A significant talking point in diplomatic circles is the health of the 73-year-old Xi. After he skipped the official dinner at Rashtrapati Bhavan immediately after the BRICS Summit got over, the Delhi grapevine murmured Xi had a sudden stroke to exhaustion after a packed schedule. ThinkChina, a Singapore-based publication under Lianhe Zaobao, used proprietary algorithmic analysis to examine Xi’s movements after he left. It reported “no significant anomalies were observed in Xi’s movements when he boarded the plane on September 13 for the return journey; and at the meeting the day before”. His measured step-length asymmetry was 0.33 per cent, while his left-right auto correlation was 0.6910. The analysis concluded that “this suggests that Xi’s cardiopulmonary function is quite good”. When Modi reportedly asked Xi twice whether everything was okay, the algorithm found predominantly positive emotional responses, with a confidence level of 93 per cent. However, such readings must be treated cautiously: movement and body-language analysis alone cannot reliably diagnose a medical condition.

If the algorithm is right, guessing what it means for Indo-Sino relations is playing the 2,500-year-old Weiqi, one of the most complex strategy games in human history despite its simple rules. The players must surround more territory than the opponent while capturing enemy stones by fully surrounding them. The game reflects Taoist concepts of balance, flow, yin and yang, and strategic patience rather than immediate aggressive annihilation. Xi Jinping is an emperor-leader who methodically rebuilt the Chinese state around clear national priorities. The shatranj equivalent to Weiqi is sente: the ultimate form of initiative or tempo. Hence, India cannot afford to play passive moves just because its opponent threatened something small. Instead, it must ask: “Do I really need to answer that, or can I play a bigger move elsewhere?” Retaining sente will dictate the pace of the entire match. – The New Indian Express, 1 November 2026

› Ravi Shankar is an author and cartoonist. He is currently a columist and editor at The New Indian Express in New Delhi.

Xi's Mind Graphic

Why Indian-Americans are under attack in America – Makarand R. Paranjape

Hanuman statue in Sugarland, Texas.

Indian-Americans find themselves in an unenviable predicament. Their extraordinary educational, economic and professional achievements, instead of guaranteeing acceptance, have made them targets of suspicion, jealousy and, increasingly, outright hatred. – Makarand R. Paranjape

Indian-Americans may be facing their worst wave of hostility in the United States in half a century. The irony is that they are under attack not because they have failed to make it in the US, but because they have succeeded so spectacularly.

Caught between an increasingly identitarian, socialist Left and a resentful, revanchist Right, they find themselves in an unenviable predicament. Their extraordinary educational, economic and professional achievements, instead of guaranteeing acceptance, have made them targets of suspicion, jealousy and, increasingly, outright hatred.

Consider two recent incidents, seemingly unrelated but symptomatic of this disturbing development. Nineteen-year-old Alexandros Paporakis, a self-proclaimed neo-Nazi, attempted to open fire outside a temple. Luckily, his rifle jammed. He subsequently spoke of returning to finish his murderous mission. Fortunately, his co-workers alerted the police, who arrested him.

One wonders at their miraculous escape: what saved hundreds of Hindu worshippers from a possible massacre at the Sri Venkateswara Swami Temple in Aurora, near Chicago, on October 11? Among those worshipping that day were Democratic Congressman Raja Krishnamoorthi and his family. One shudders to imagine what might have happened had the rifle fired.

Some devotees might attribute their miraculous escape to Lord Venkateswara’s protection. Some would rule out divine intervention and point simply to a malfunctioning rifle. My question is different: Why should Hindu worshippers in America become targets of murderous racial hatred?

Vivek Ramaswamy, the brilliant, ambitious Indian-origin Republican gubernatorial candidate in Ohio, has landed himself in an entirely avoidable controversy. His campaign released an advertisement featuring the estranged mother of his Democratic opponent, Amy Acton, accusing her daughter of dishonesty. Given Acton’s traumatic childhood and allegations of sexual abuse, the advertisement struck many as gratuitously cruel.

Even Republican Governor Mike DeWine demanded its withdrawal. Could this prove a turning point? A mid-October poll already showed Ramaswamy trailing Acton by seven percentage points.

But apart from a tasteless and offensive ad, might there be another factor? Perhaps voters in this predominantly white Midwestern state may not be comfortable with a Hindu governor of Indian origin. Any excuse, including being vegetarian or walking about barefoot at home, might be enough to tilt voter sentiment against him. The advertisement could give wavering voters an excuse to reject Ramaswamy without interrogating their own prejudices.

Remember Bobby Jindal, the Indian-origin Republican who converted to Catholicism? He successfully governed conservative Louisiana for two terms, but his presidential ambitions came to nothing. Religious assimilation, evidently, is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for political success.

Let me state my larger proposition bluntly. Indian-Americans may be facing their most uncomfortable political moment in half a century. Why? Because on the Left, large sections of the so-called Progressives have moved beyond traditional liberalism towards an amalgam of radical identity politics, anti-capitalism and accommodation of Islamist political movements. Hindu Americans, notwithstanding their minority status, can be portrayed as privileged white-adjacents, whose legitimate concerns about discrimination and religious freedom deserve little sympathy. Yet religious liberty cannot be selective. Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Jews, Sikhs and others must enjoy equal constitutional protection.

The Right presents a different problem.

Indian-Americans are among America’s most successful immigrant communities. According to Pew Research Center, Indian-headed households had a median annual income exceeding $151,000 in 2023. Their educational and professional achievements are equally impressive.

Instead of celebrating this contribution, parts of Maga increasingly regard Indian professionals as economic competitors, even interlopers stealing the jobs of US-born native Americans. Read that as fellow whites. Yes, let’s face it. Maga anti-Indianism has not only Christian fundamentalist but also racist undertones.

The Trump administration has imposed all kinds of barriers on new H-1Bs, including an extraordinary $100,000 fee on certain new H-1B petitions. Although federal courts have blocked it, Trump has come up with a new $103,265 fee proposed by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) through a a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking $108,000 fee on new applications. This move is considered legally more resilient than the earlier, $100,000 fee. Vice President J.D. Vance has also attacked abuses of H-1B visas, using some unparliamentary epithets. But reforming immigration is one thing; vilifying immigrants quite another. America cannot maintain technological supremacy by discouraging the very scientists, engineers, physicians and entrepreneurs who help sustain it.

There is also a distinction that fashionable multiculturalism has been reluctant to acknowledge. Not all immigrant communities are identical in their educational backgrounds, cultural practices, religious beliefs or attitudes towards integration. To pretend otherwise is intellectual dishonesty.

Consider Britain’s appalling grooming-gang scandals. In notorious cases, including Rotherham and Rochdale, networks of predominantly Muslim Pakistani-origin men sexually exploited vulnerable underage girls. This was done in a systematic and prolonged manner while the police and judicial authorities, apparently, turned a blind eye.

But an underlying question remains to be addressed: why persist with the indiscriminate and blatantly inaccurate designation ‘Asian’ when nearly all of these rapists were Muslim, not to mention Pakistani? What do Hindus, Sikhs, Bangladeshis, Nepalis or other Asian communities have to do with these criminal networks? Why should they bear the shame?

Ayaan Hirsi Ali, the Somali-born former Dutch parliamentarian who suffered female genital mutilation herself, has spent decades challenging the horribly sexist, even misogynist, practices of Sharia law in Muslim-majority countries around the world. Her books Infidel, Heretic and Prey expose the dangers of refusing to examine cultural and theological assumptions.

Swedish research on rape convictions has also identified disturbing disparities associated with immigrant backgrounds. It is Muslim immigrants whose numbers are disproportionately high among perpetrators of sexual crimes. Such findings demand investigation, not ideological suppression. Although we mustn’t simplistically assume religious causation, religious and cultural differences should be investigated honestly rather than concealed beneath politically convenient labels.

The irony is that Indian-Americans, despite their conspicuous achievements, are themselves increasingly subjected to indiscriminate suspicion. Even though they are among the most law-abiding and non-violent of all immigrant communities. Racial prejudice compounds economic resentment. The evidently white-supremacist motivation behind the Aurora attack cannot be explained away as concern about jobs or immigration.

But another political calculation may be involved. Indian-Americans have traditionally leaned Democratic. Some MAGA strategists may therefore reason: why bother courting a community that won’t vote Republican anyway? Yet Indian-Americans are hardly politically homogeneous. Ramaswamy himself, and the prominence of Usha Vance, demonstrate their growing presence within Republican circles.

What, then, should Indian-Americans do?

My answer is simple: organise, participate, influence. For too long, this remarkably successful community has concentrated on education, professional advancement, entrepreneurship and family prosperity, leaving political activism to others.

That must change.

Indian-Americans need stronger civic associations, effective lobbying, greater political participation and a confident presence in public debates. Hindu Americans, particularly, must defend their religious freedoms through constitutional institutions rather than occasional expressions of outrage.

But integration also demands reciprocity.

Indian-Americans must not retreat into comfortable cultural ghettos. They must learn more about America’s history, traditions and institutions. Participate in neighbourhood organisations, school boards, voluntary associations and public life. Build friendships and alliances beyond ethnic boundaries. Above all, they mustn’t allow their identities to be defined by those who dislike them.

The United States remains one of humanity’s boldest experiments in accommodating differences within a common constitutional framework. Indian-Americans have benefited enormously from that promise and contributed handsomely to its fulfilment.

The question is not whether they can become sufficiently American to satisfy their detractors, but whether America can remain sufficiently faithful to its founding ideals to embrace them as they are. – Firstpost, 28 October 2026

› Makarand R. Paranjape, author and public intellectual, is currently Sri Aurobindo Chair, Vedere University & Director of Education, AHCP LLC.

Shooter Alexandros Paporakis and the Sri Venkateswara Swami Temple in Aurora, Illinois.

Gen-Z: Revolution is the ballot, not the barricade – Yuvraj Pokharna

Gen-Z stident protest at New Delhi 2026.

Bharat at 2047 is not built on barricades. It is built in classrooms, laboratories, boardrooms, farms, and yes, in voting booths. The ‘Suvarn Kaal’ does not wait for those busy performing revolution for an audience that does not have Bharat’s interests at heart. – Yuvraj Pokharna

Let me speak directly to my Gen-Z, the Yuva of Bharat. That is the generation I write for, argue for, and refuse to give up on. You are being played! Not by the government. Not by the system, but by a well-oiled, well-funded, ideologically rehearsed ecosystem—one with a singular agenda—to manufacture a generation of permanent protesters out of a generation that was born to build.

India is growing at a pace that is forcing even the IMF to revise its numbers upward. This very quarter, the Fund was compelled to upgrade India’s growth projection from 6.5 per cent to 7 per cent. From sui to space, from UPI to ISRO, the Bharat growth story is not a government press release. It is documented, data-backed, and a globally acknowledged reality. The Indian Yuva is at the centre of that story as engineers, entrepreneurs, coders, creators, and contributors to a civilisation reclaiming its rightful place. And yet, someone wants you on the street instead.

Let us be clear about something. India has earned its revolutions. The rebellion against British colonial plunder was not anarchy; it was civilisational self-defence. The JP Andolan against Indira Gandhi’s Emergency was not disorder, it was democracy fighting back against a despotic ruler who had strangled the Constitution with her own hands. Those were different times, drastic times: times when the protest was the only constitutional tool left standing. Those times are not these times. When a democratically elected government is functioning within its full constitutional mandate, when the judiciary is not just intact but actively engaged, when elections are held on schedule, when the EVM remains the most powerful instrument of change available to every single citizen, anarchy dressed in the language of constitutionalism is not resistance. It is sabotage.

Look at the pattern. Because there is always a pattern. JNU erupts and two faces emerge for national primetime: Kanhaiya Kumar and Umar Khalid. The anti-CAA protests ignite and Sharjil Imam arrives, complete with his maps and his proposals for cutting the Northeast off from Bharat. Jamia burns and the ecosystem gifts us its heroes. And now, from the current round of mobilisation, we are being asked to accept Neha Bora—after the July rounds of protests that gave us cockroaches or so they would like to call themselves—AISA president, Rahul Gandhi’s new poster girl, and Marxist agitator as the new youth icon of India.

Rai ka pahad banana. A trimmed fingernail elevated into a certificate of martyrdom.

Here is what Bora actually said on record, in a video address to the Socialist Students’ Front conference in Bangladesh: “We know that the Gen-Z movement that we are seeing everywhere in this country first started in Bangladesh. Congratulations to you for showing us the way.” Bangladesh. A country where a student-led uprising led to over 500 deaths, forced a prime minister to flee, and plunged a neighbouring nation into chaos. That is the model being held up for your inspiration, Gen Z of Bharat.

And standing alongside her at a press conference at the Press Club of India today, senior advocate Prashant Bhushan said this – also on record: “There will definitely be a regime change. We all want a regime change.”

Not at the ballot box. Not through elections. Through the street. When Bangladeshi anarchists and Pakistani handles applaud these protests, what exactly are they celebrating? India’s democratic health? Or India’s destabilisation? The foreign connection is not a conspiracy theory. It is a documented, observable, consistent feature of every manufactured uprising this ecosystem has produced.

The government’s decision to denotify Jantar Mantar as a protest venue and redirect demonstrations to Ramlila Maidan is being spun as petrification. Let us apply basic logic here. Ramlila Maidan is the same ground where JP Narayan stood and shook a despotic government to its foundations. If the government were afraid of protest, it would not have designated one of the most historically significant protest grounds in the nation’s memory as the space for dissent.

It has not banned protest. It has maintained constitutional order. And if at any point it overstepped that mandate, the judiciary, neither absent nor captured, would have intervened. It has not needed to. Because the government has not overstepped.

My Gen-Z, let me say this with the love and the sharpness that this moment demands.

You are not the problem. You are the target.

This ecosystem needs your energy, your numbers, your social media fluency, and your genuine frustration with real issues—issues that matter and resonate with the youths—to fuel a political project that has nothing to do with your future and everything to do with its own survival.

Neha Bora did not build anything for you. Neither does she intend to. And that Yogendra Yadav, born as Salim Yadav—who declared “Sansad se nahi, sadak se faisla hoga”—is not fighting for your future. Prashant Bhushan, who wants regime change through the street and has previously spoken of revolution and bloodshed, is not your ally. They are using you. Do not be the fuel for someone else’s fire. If the government has failed you on any count—and no government is above that accountability—your weapon is the ballot. That is the most powerful instrument of peaceful, civilisational revolution ever designed. JP used the street because the ballot box had been suspended. You have not been robbed of yours. Use it.

Bharat at 2047 is not built on barricades. It is built in classrooms, laboratories, boardrooms, farms, and yes, in voting booths. The ‘Suvarn Kaal’ does not wait for those busy performing revolution for an audience that does not have Bharat’s interests at heart. You are not here to live in ‘delulu’. You are not here to merely find the ‘solulu’. You are here to become it. – News18, 20 October 2026

› Yuvraj Pokharna is a Surat-based educator, columnist, and social activist. He is the author of the book Hindutva For Gen Z.

Prashant Bhushan, Neha Bora and Abhijeet Dipke

There was never a Nazi Out-of-India theory – Koenraad Elst

Out of India Map

The objective finality of Sheldon Pollock’s thesis is to blacken the Out-of-India Theory (OIT) by associating it with Hitler’s National Socialism. Reality, however, is just the opposite: more even than other Europeans, the Nazis espoused and upheld the Aryan Invastion Theory (AIT). – Dr. Koenraad Elst

While we were working on the argumentation against the Aryan Invasion Theory (AIT), an improper and utterly false argument against the presumed association of the rivaling Out-of-India Theory (OIT) with Nazi Germany was being prepared in high places. This becomes clear from a refutation of the latter in a paper published by the International Journal of Hindu Studies (no.16, 2012, p.189-252), and written by the German scholar Reinhold Grünendahl (Göttingen): “History in the making: on Sheldon Pollock’s ‘NS Indology’ and Vishwa Adluri’s ‘Pride and Prejudice’”.

The homeland debate

Ultimately, a question of ancient history, such as the location of the homeland of the Indo-European language family inside or outside of India, will not be decided by its real or putative association with political tendencies in the modern age. Thus, when Hindus are writing for the umpteenth time that the AIT stems from colonialism and racism, they may be wrong or they may be right, but at any rate they are wasting their breath. Historians know that even a theory-generated history plays out in a time when other concerns were at stake than in the present by the wrong motives may prove to be right, and even a point of view stemming from noble political positions may be wrong. We all would like to domesticate history into political usefulness for today, but have to acknowledge that it doesn’t work that way.

All the same, the AIT school do occasionally try to blacken the Hindu nationalist movement’s newfound enthusiasm for the OIT with a wrong political association, viz. by fitting it into their well-established narrative that somehow this is a “fascist” movement. Thus, in a newspaper column, Robert Zydenbos (“An obscurantist argument”, Indian Express, 12-12-1993) tried to associate Navaratna Rajaram’s arguments for the OIT with Adolf Hitler’s National Socialism. More crassly, Yoginder Sikand (“Exploding the Aryan myth”, Observer of Business and Politics, 30-10-1993) likewise tried to link the OIT with Nazi Germany, playing on their common concern for (but diametrically opposite interpretation of) the term Arya.

Of course, nobody who follows the debate, closely or even from afar, can be taken in by this. Very obviously, the Nazis themselves never believed in the OIT but were more ardent than most in espousing the AIT. Practically all Westerners at the time, and many Indians as well (including the Hindu nationalist leader of the Congress party, Balagangadhara Tilak, and the ideologue of the Hindutva movement, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar), took the AIT for granted. The Nazis had an extra reason for putting their faith in it, viz. that the AIT served as the perfect illustration to the Nazi worldview. The Aryan immigrants had demonstrated their superiority, they had sought to protect it by instituting a colour-based (to the Nazis: race-based) caste system, and they had lost part of their European quality by succumbing to race-mixing nonetheless. So, if anyone should be likened to Hitler, it is the AIT advocates themselves, including Zydenbos and Sikand. The OIT school rarely misses a chance to highlight this political identification of the AIT: with British imperialism as well as with European racism epitomized by the Nazis.

We may assume that Zydenbos was a newcomer to this debate, that he objected to the OIT in good faith and that he hadn’t informed himself of the Nazi view on the homeland question. But two decades down the line, the AIT belief has definitely lost its innocence. And already back then, a specialist like Columbia professor Sheldon Pollock published a paper titled: “Deep Orientalism? Notes on Sanskrit and power beyond the Raj” (in Carol A. Breckenridge and Peter van der Veer, eds.: Orientalism and the Postcolonial Predicament: Perspectives on South Asia, UPenn Press, 1993, p.76-133), which includes a chapter titled “Ex Oriente Nox: Indology in the Total State” (p.86-96). He and his acolytes have since kept on elaborating this thesis, viz. that Germany invested much in Indology and used it in its project of self-definition as “Aryans” contrasting with the “Semites”. A recent example of this polemic is Vishwa Adluri’s paper in Pollock’s defence, “Pride and Prejudice: Orientalism and German Indology” (International Journal of Hindu Studies, no. 15, 2011, p.253-294).

While we, both in the OIT and AIT camp, were concentrating on the scientific evidence pertaining to the homeland and to the direction of the Indo-European expansion, someone somewhere was working on a large-scale and truly daring attempt to finally link the OIT to the National Socialist regime. Nonetheless, a Hindu industrialist recently donated Pollock a fabulous sum of money for his work on Sanskrit literature, trusting him more with this heritage than other Indologists including the native scholars, both traditional and university-trained, who are far better at home in Sanskrit and financially far cheaper than an American academic. So, this highly reputed Sanskrit specialist sharpened his long-standing hatred of the Hindu nationalist movement into a paper alleging that Indology in general and the OIT in particular was much beloved of the Nazi establishment.

Edward Said

In this paper, Pollock at first seeks to supplement Edward Said’s unjustly famous thesis Orientalism (1978) with the German chapter which Said purposely left out. If truthful, such a chapter would have refuted Said’s whole theory, viz. that “Orientalism” was nothing but the intellectual chapter of the political-economic colonial entreprise. The mainstay of “Orientalist” scholarship was Central Europe, then thoroughly German-speaking at least at the intellectual level. Prussia only had colonies at a late date and far from the lands that interested the Orientalists, while the other countries involved, including the Austro-Hungarian empire, had no colonies at all. In the colonial countries too, many Orientalists were by no means part of the colonial entreprise (pace Said’s conspiracy theory), but in the German-speaking world, there was not even a colonial entreprise to integrate the Orientalist endeavour in; yet Orientalism flourished there like nowhere else. Moreover, Orientalism took wing when the Austro-Hungarian Empire’s Oriental neighbor, the Ottoman Empire, was by no means a colony but a threat and an equal trading-partner.

Indeed, even in its better-developed “British” part, Said’s theory was deeply flawed from the beginning, and the numerous errors of detail as well as the general error of his theory have ably been pointed out by Robert Irwin (For Lust of Knowing: the Orientalists and Their Enemies, Allan Lane, London, 2006) and Ibn Warraq (Defending the West. A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism, Prometheus, Amherst, NY, 2007). A comprehensive work on German-language Oriental scholarship has been produced by Suzanne Marchand (German Orientalism in the Age of Empire: Religion, Race and Scholarship, German Historical Institute, Washington DC and Cambridge University Press, 2009). With the benefit of hindsight, we can now pass judgment on Said’s influential publication which has seriously damaged the fair name of the academic discipline called “Orientalism”.

Academics who still rely on Said’s thesis, actually rely on a profoundly mistaken and highly politicized piece of scholarship. His thesis is a thin attempt at justification for anti-Westernism. Much as this is in vogue among Hindus, they are only making fools of themselves by espousing Said’s conspiracy theory. For everyone, it is academically weak and factually full of mistakes, but for Muslims at least, they would be supporting their own man. They would be cheering for a Dhimmi, someone upholding Islamic causes, in that as well as in other books. In supporting Said, Pollock is true to his own camp, i.e. the anti-Hindu coalition. But for Hindus, there is nothing in it, they are cheering for someone serving a declared enemy.

What Nazi rule really meant for Orientalism

Grünendahl cites many examples where Pollock and his defender Adluri manipulate quotations to make past authors witnesses for their accusations. I vaguely knew that Pollock was wrong in associating the OIT with National Socialism, but not that he was so spectacularly wrong. His thesis is first of all that India was a central concern for the Nazis. This is put forward most emphatically (but only with bluff) by Pollock and, on his authority, generally taken for granted. Adluri elaborates that Germany was very worried about building its “identity” as contrasting with the Semitic heritage and the Semitic people in their midst, and used India for that purpose.

But Grünendahl shows from old and neutral sources that the Indology departments received no special attention, that they were small compared to Ancient Near-Eastern Studies, Sinology etc., and that the Nazi period showed no special interest in Orientalism in general or Indology in particular. If anything, they suffered in their orientation on India from the reigning emphasis on “Indo-Germanic studies”.

Marchand notes that the number of German Oriental scholars as a whole fell from 360 in 1931 to 180 in 1940. [2009:488] What connection she cites between Indology and the Nazis [2009:499] is wholly based on Pollock, who estimates that one-third of the (only!) ca. twenty-five Indology professors in the Third Reich were active in the National Socialist party or in the SS. This is the only time she cites him in her 526-page book. (She also naïvely gives credence to other anti-Hindu scholars such as Reza Pirbhai, p.311.) According to her: “Worst of all among the Indologist collaborators was Walter Wüst, the Vedic specialist at the University of Munich who became the director of the SS Ahnenerbe.” [p.499] But Wüst is not known to have championed the OIT, on the contrary. The Nazi regime’s favourite historian H.K.F. Günther believed the homeland lay in Southeastern Europe. This was the reigning opinion in Europe, challenged only by some Nazis who insisted on Germany or Scandinavia as the homeland. All of them agreed that the Indo-European language family had only reached India through an Aryan invasion.

Let us add that Marchand agrees to include among the Nazi Indologists Paul Thieme, the revered teacher of Michael Witzel; and he was, like his more militant pupil, a believer in the AIT. According to Marchand, one of the Nazi concerns in Oriental scholarship was “the refutation of the Jewish origins of monotheism” (p.489) namely in Mazdeism. The picture of religion in National Socialism was complex and diverse, but belief in the superiority of monotheism was unchallenged. Like racism, it was then part of the general consensus.

She also notes that: “Among the Islamicists, there were also numerous collaborators (…) things looked rather promising for this bunch in the period 1936-39” when the Nazi leaders Joseph Goebbels and Baldur von Schirach toured the Middle East, and the Islamologists were used to liaise with Muslim leaders like the Jerusalem Mufti, so that they “successfully disseminated Nazi ideas throughout the Middle East”. [2009:490] Wouldn’t that be a good topic for Orientalist scholars: Islamic-Nazi similarities as the reason for Nazi-Muslim friendships?

The Nazi concern for “Aryans” speaking “Indo-Germanic” (innocently so named after its two extremes: Indo-Aryan in Bengal and Germanic in Iceland) or Indo-European, now and originally conceived as a language family but then also conceived as a racial unit, couldn’t seriously be bothered with India. Their main concern was with the North, so Grünendahl argues:

“The fundamental flaw of Pollock’s narrative is that it hinges entirely on the exact reverse of the ‘Nordic’ notion. This reversal, which provides the basis for the ‘founding myth’ of the entire discourse machinery he set in motion, is enshrined in the grotesque proposition that ‘the Germans … continued, however subliminally, to hold the nineteenth-century conviction that the origin of European civilization was to be found in India (or at least that India constituted a genetically related sibling)’ (1993:77) Even to the Romantic period [end of 18th, early 19th century, when this notion was upheld by Johann Herder], this assertion only holds with considerable qualifications. (…) To make it the basis for theorizing any aspect of the NS period is rendered absurd by the above-mentioned texts alone”. [p.199]

Hitler on the Hindus

Reference is to texts revealing Hitler’s position on the Hindus. In 1920 already, he laid his cards on the table, and would never waver from this position, not in Mein Kampf, which disparages Hindus as also German neo-Pagans, not in his speeches nor in his wartime table talks. There he had evolved to mocking religion in general and his native Catholicism specifically, though he appreciated its organization and mass psychology and its anti-caste way of recruiting its priests from the people rather than from a separate priestly caste (yes, Hitler was also a comrade-at-arms of Pollock in their common anti-Brahminism). He only knew of the Hindus through the lens of the AIT:

“While Hitler does refer to ‘the Hindus’, he does so not with the intent to employ them as distant relatives in the ‘creation of Indo-German as counteridentity’ (Pollock 1993:83), but merely as an illustration of ‘racial decline’ (Rassensenkung) due to the destruction of ‘national purity’ (nationale Reinheit.)” (p.218, with reference to Adolf Hitler 1980 (1920): “Warum sind wir Antisemiten?” in Eberhard Jäckel and Axel Kuhn, eds: Hitlers sämtliche Aufzeichnungen, 1905-1924, p.184-204: specifically p.195-196)

So, Hitler’s rare utterance on the Hindus was a racial interpretation of the AIT. These are his own words (1980/1920:195): “Wir wissen, dass die Hindu in Indien ein Volk sind, gemischt aus den hochstehenden arischen Einwanderern und der dunkelschwarzen Urbevölkerung, und dass dieses Volk heute die folgen trägt; denn es ist auch das Sklavenvolk einer Rasse, die uns in vielen Punkten nahezu als zweite Judenheit erscheinen darf.” (“We know that the Hindus in India are a people mixed from the lofty Aryan immigrants and the dark black aboriginal population, and that this people is bearing the consequences today; for it is also the slave people of a race that almost seems like a second Jewry.”)

For Grünendahl, this is merely an example of how the primary sources of German history contradict the free-for-all that amateur historians make of it, in this case the manipulated narrative by Sheldon Pollock. He sounds like defending Germany’s true history against American (and then, by imitation, Indian) distortions. Probably he doesn’t realize that this distortion, about the presumed Nazi love for the OIT, constitutes Pollock’s ultimate motive. We don’t want to pretend to read inside a man’s skull, so we will not speak out on his intimate motives. But the objective finality of his thesis is at any rate to blacken the OIT by associating it with National-Socialism. Reality, however, is just the opposite: more even than other Europeans, the Nazis espoused and upheld the AIT. Hitler-Pollock, same struggle! – Swarajya Magazine, 9 December 2012

› Dr. Koenraad Elst is a Belgium Orientalist and Voice of India author who often visits India to lecture.

See also

India (Meluhha) trade by sea with Mesopotamia ca. 2500 BCE.

Durga we worship, women we doubt – Tejusvi Shukla

Durga

Dharma is not set once and preserved in amber; it is re-established in every age. Civilisations endure by shedding what has worn out so that what is eternal may continue. Even the Constitution of India, barely 76 years old, has been amended over a hundred times because the society it serves is alive. Continuity depends on change. – Tejusvi Shukla

Navratri brings nine nights of a civilisation remembering who it believes holds up the universe. Each night unveils another face of Shakti, and the journey ends on Vijayadashami, or Bijoya, when Durga stands over the slain Mahishasura. She is not the rescued but the rescuer.

There is something extraordinary about a culture whose very word for power, shakti, is feminine. That inheritance is also a mirror. A society that bows before the Devi for nine nights sometimes returns, on the tenth morning, to imagining her daughters as fragile, and calls that culture. Bijoya leaves us one question: what do we keep of her once the pandals come down? The answer is not to worship less but to let worship mean what it says.

The Goddess who speaks for herself

The idea is ancient. In the Devi Suktam (RV 10.125), the rishika Vak Ambhrini does not pray to the Goddess. She speaks as her:

Aham rashtri sangamani vasunam chikitushee prathama yajniyanam.

I am the rashtri, the sovereign of the universe, the knower of Ultimate Reality.

This is not a goddess waiting to be defended. She is sovereignty, knowledge and righteous force, declared in a woman’s own voice. The same tradition gave us Gargi, who questioned Yajnavalkya, and Maitreyi, who chose knowledge over wealth.

What the shastras also said

The Dharmashastras are often held responsible for the distance between the Goddess and the woman, though the record is richer than that. The Manusmriti carries the much-quoted

Na stree swatantryam arhati (9.3). Yet the same text declares: Yatra naryastu pujyante ramante tatra devatah (3.56).

Where women are honoured, the gods rejoice; where they are not, every rite is fruitless.

Kautilya’s Arthashastra, in its chapter on the superintendent of yarn (2.23), fines any officer who looks upon a woman worker’s face or speaks of anything but the work, in a workshop where the lamp is kept only as bright as the yarn requires. The burden of propriety fell on the official, not the woman. The text secured the space; it did not confine her.

How the two voices came to part

If both voices belong to one tradition, how did they come to part? The divergence between the exalted status of the feminine in sacred thought and the lived position of women was neither instantaneous nor uniform. It grew through the interaction of normative texts, customary practice, social institutions and changing material conditions. The authority of Vak Ambhrini, Gargi and Maitreyi coexisted with later juridical formulations that increasingly located women within the structures of the family, and even within the Dharmashastra tradition the record cannot be reduced to a single position.

Every text carries the worldview of the world that wrote it. The hymns belong to an age that made room for women as seers. The legal literature that followed was composed as settled households, inherited property and lineage became society’s central concerns, and its authors, writing as men of their time, spoke of women chiefly in relation to the family. Even the verse on independence is framed as guardianship, with father, husband and son each keeping watch in turn. It reads less as a verdict on a woman’s worth than as the assumption of a household-centred world. Over centuries, custom repeated those assumptions until they felt like scripture.

What changed, then, was not the disappearance of the feminine principle from our religious imagination, but its uneven translation into social practice. Shakti remained divine, sovereign and unconstrained in the sacred sphere, while the autonomy of women in the social sphere became progressively mediated by custom, family structures and patriarchal readings of tradition. Neither the reverence nor the reflex is foreign to us. Both are ours.

A civilisation that is alive

Which one we carry forward is a question the tradition itself prepared us to answer, for it never claimed to be fixed. The very Manusmriti that records the household’s rules also observes that dharma differs from age to age:

Anye kritayuge dharmas tretayam dwapare apare; anye kaliyuge nrinam yuga-hrasanurupatah (1.85).

Sri Krishna gives that understanding its grammar: Dharma-samsthapanarthaya sambhavami yuge yuge (Bhagavad Gita 4.8).

Dharma is not set once and preserved in amber; it is re-established in every age. Civilisations endure by shedding what has worn out so that what is eternal may continue. Even the Constitution of India, barely 76 years old, has been amended over a hundred times because the society it serves is alive. Continuity depends on change.

To read the old texts as living thought is therefore not to defy them but to follow them. Their authors answered the questions of their age; ours is to answer our own. Restricting a daughter’s movement instead of making the street safe for her, or questioning a woman’s clothes rather than an offender’s conduct, is not preservation. It is a quiet disservice to a civilisation whose own statecraft fined an officer for a lamp that burned too bright. The Saraswati we invoke before examinations holds the book and the veena in her own hands; her daughters can hold their ambitions the same way.

The victory we celebrate

The Devi Mahatmya tells how the gods, unable to defeat Mahishasura, pooled their radiance into one feminine form and placed their weapons in her hands. She did not need their protection. She needed only their trust, and she won. Its best-loved hymn salutes her in every being:

Ya Devi Sarvabhuteshu Shakti-rupena Samsthita.

In every being, not only on the altar.

The hymn to the sovereign Devi was voiced by a woman. The rules of the household were written by men of their age. What is written next belongs to us, for every generation of this civilisation is handed the same pen. The Devi has already answered what a woman is. The question that remains is ours: when a daughter stands at the door with a book in one hand and a dream in the other, which of our two voices will she hear?

Shubho Bijoya! – The Pioneer, 20 October 2026

› Tejusvi Shukla is the Assistant Director (Research) at Bharat Ki Soch. Her focus of research is internal security, left-wing extremism, medical diplomacy, and the weaponization of social media. 

Women apply vermilion on each other's face during 'Sindoor Khel' on Vijayadashmi the tenth day of Durga Puja in Lucknow.